E
embedding-shape
As various LLMs become more and more popular, so does comments with "I asked Gemini, and Gemini said ....".
While the guidelines were written (and iterated on) during a different time, it seems like it might be time to have a discussion about if those sort of comments should be welcomed on HN or not.
Some examples:
What do you think? Should responses that basically boil down to "I asked $LLM about $X, and here is what $LLM said:" be allowed on HN, and the guidelines updated to state that people shouldn't critique it (similar to other guidelines currently), or should a new guideline be added to ask people from refrain from copy-pasting large LLM responses into the comments, or something else completely?
Comments URL: Ask HN: Should "I asked $AI, and it said" replies be forbidden in HN guidelines? | Hacker News
Points: 140
# Comments: 92
Continue reading...
While the guidelines were written (and iterated on) during a different time, it seems like it might be time to have a discussion about if those sort of comments should be welcomed on HN or not.
Some examples:
- I hate to say it, but faced with 74 pages of text outside my domain expertise, I... | Hacker News
- I asked Grok to visualize this: https://grok.com/share/bGVnYWN5_463d51c8-d473-47... | Hacker News
- I asked ChatGPT to make this more readable since it's a mix of satire and actual... | Hacker News
What do you think? Should responses that basically boil down to "I asked $LLM about $X, and here is what $LLM said:" be allowed on HN, and the guidelines updated to state that people shouldn't critique it (similar to other guidelines currently), or should a new guideline be added to ask people from refrain from copy-pasting large LLM responses into the comments, or something else completely?
Comments URL: Ask HN: Should "I asked $AI, and it said" replies be forbidden in HN guidelines? | Hacker News
Points: 140
# Comments: 92
Continue reading...